Tennessee Volunteer to $170 Million Man: Garrett Crochet's Record-Breaking Red Sox Gamble

In the high-stakes world of Major League Baseball, few stories capture the imagination quite like a player transforming from college standout to franchise cornerstone in the span of just a few years. But even by those standards, Garrett Crochet's meteoric rise from Tennessee Volunteer to $170 million man represents one of the most remarkable journeys in recent baseball history.

When the Boston Red Sox signed Crochet to a six-year, $170 million contract extension on March 31, 2025—just four days after his first start as their Opening Day pitcher—they weren't just making a financial commitment. They were placing an enormous bet on a left-handed pitcher whose career has been defined by both incredible potential and significant risk.

The Volunteer Foundation

Garrett Crochet's path to baseball stardom began in the heart of SEC country, where he spent three transformative seasons with the Tennessee Volunteers from 2018 to 2020. For a program that has consistently produced major league talent, Crochet's arrival represented the kind of high-ceiling prospect that championship programs are built around.

His journey to Knoxville wasn't straightforward. Originally selected by the Milwaukee Brewers in the 34th round of the 2017 MLB Draft out of Ocean Springs High School in Mississippi, Crochet chose to honor his commitment to Tennessee—a decision that would prove transformative for both player and program.

At Tennessee, Crochet's development followed a compelling arc that showcased both his immense talent and the challenges that would later define his professional career:

Tennessee Volunteers Career (2018-2020)
Overall Record: 10-9
ERA: 4.64
Strikeouts: 139
Saves: 13
Appearances: 36 games (13 starts)

While those numbers might not jump off the page, they tell the story of a pitcher who was learning to harness exceptional velocity and developing the skills that would eventually make him one of baseball's most dominant arms. His freshman season in 2018 was particularly challenging, as he posted a 5-6 record with a 5.51 ERA while adjusting to the rigors of SEC competition.

The breakthrough came during his sophomore year in 2019, when Crochet began to show flashes of the dominance that scouts had projected. Despite missing the SEC Tournament due to a broken jaw suffered in his last regular season start, he demonstrated significant improvement with a 5-3 record and a 4.02 ERA.

The Shortened Junior Year That Changed Everything

Crochet's junior season in 2020 was when everything came together—and when his professional future was accelerated beyond anyone's expectations. Baseball America named him a preseason First-Team All-American, and he was placed on the watch list for the Golden Spikes Award, given annually to the top amateur baseball player.

Unfortunately, the COVID-19 pandemic cut his final college season short after just one start, in which he threw 3.2 scoreless innings with six strikeouts. That brief showing was enough to cement his status as one of the top prospects in the 2020 MLB Draft.

The truncated season didn't diminish Crochet's draft stock. In fact, it may have enhanced his mystique, as scouts had seen enough to project him as a frontline starter with the kind of electric stuff that can dominate at the highest level.

Draft Day Dreams Realized

When the Chicago White Sox selected Crochet with the 11th overall pick in the 2020 MLB Draft, they were betting on the rare combination of present ability and future potential. The $4.5 million signing bonus reflected their belief that they had found a pitcher who could contribute immediately while developing into a cornerstone starter.

Crochet's path to the majors was unlike almost any other in recent memory. On September 18, 2020, he became the first player from the 2020 draft class to reach the major leagues—a testament to both his advanced skill level and the White Sox's confidence in his ability to handle big-league hitters.

Even more remarkably, Crochet became just the 22nd player in MLB history to go straight from the draft to the majors without playing in the minor leagues, joining an exclusive club that includes only the most polished and ready prospects.

The Injury Setback That Tested Everything

Crochet's early professional success made his subsequent injury struggles all the more challenging. After showing flashes of brilliance in limited appearances during 2020 and 2021, disaster struck in 2022 when he was diagnosed with a torn ulnar collateral ligament, requiring Tommy John surgery.

The procedure, performed on April 5, 2022, threatened to derail the promising career of a pitcher who had shown 100+ mph velocity and the kind of swing-and-miss stuff that defines elite closers. For the White Sox and Crochet himself, the surgery represented a crossroads moment that would determine whether his ceiling could ever be reached.

The Comeback That Defined a Career

Crochet's return from Tommy John surgery in 2024 wasn't just a comeback—it was a complete reinvention. The White Sox, recognizing his unique combination of velocity and control, made the decision to transition him from reliever to starter, a move that would prove transformative for both his career and his market value.

The 2024 season established Crochet as one of baseball's premier left-handed starters:

2024 Chicago White Sox Performance
Record: 6-12
ERA: 3.58
Strikeouts: 209
Innings: 146
Starts: 32
First-time All-Star

Despite pitching for a historically bad White Sox team that set the modern record with 121 losses, Crochet's individual excellence was undeniable. His 209 strikeouts in just 146 innings represented a strikeout rate that ranked among the best in baseball, while his ability to consistently work deep into games proved he could handle a starter's workload.

The combination of elite stuff, durability, and youth made Crochet one of the most coveted trade targets in baseball heading into the 2024-25 offseason.

The Boston Gamble

When the Red Sox acquired Crochet from the White Sox in December 2024, they were getting a pitcher entering his prime with the kind of upside that can anchor a championship rotation. The trade package—catcher Kyle Teel, outfielder Braden Montgomery, infielder Chase Meidroth, and right-hander Wikelman González—reflected just how highly Boston valued Crochet's potential.

The Red Sox weren't content to simply acquire Crochet; they wanted to ensure he remained in Boston for the long term. Hence the stunning contract extension signed just days after his first start.

The $170 Million Question

Crochet's six-year, $170 million extension represents one of the most aggressive investments in recent baseball history. The deal, which begins in 2026 and includes an opt-out after 2030, reflects Boston's belief that they've found their ace for the next decade.

The financial commitment is staggering when considering Crochet's injury history and the fact that he had made just 32 career starts as of the signing. But the Red Sox are betting on several factors:

Elite Stuff: Crochet's fastball consistently sits in the high-90s, complemented by a devastating slider that generates swings and misses at an elite rate.

Age and Control: At just 25 years old, Crochet is entering his prime years while still under team control, making the extension a potential bargain if he reaches his ceiling.

Market Scarcity: Top-tier starting pitching is increasingly rare and expensive in free agency, making the extension a hedge against future inflation.

Track Record: Despite his limited sample size, Crochet's 2024 performance demonstrated he can handle a full starter's workload while maintaining his effectiveness.

The Risk-Reward Calculation

The Red Sox's investment in Crochet represents the classic high-risk, high-reward scenario that defines modern baseball economics. On one hand, they're committing significant resources to a pitcher with a limited track record and injury history. On the other hand, they may have secured a frontline starter at below-market rates if Crochet continues his development.

Early returns have been promising. Crochet's 2025 season began with him being named Boston's Opening Day starter, and his early performances have validated the organization's confidence. Through his first 10 starts of the 2025 season, he has posted a 1.93 ERA while maintaining the strikeout production that made him so attractive.

The Tennessee Legacy

For the University of Tennessee baseball program, Crochet's success represents the pinnacle of their player development efforts. The Volunteers have consistently produced major league talent, but having a former player sign a $170 million contract elevates the program's profile and demonstrates the quality of coaching and development available in Knoxville.

Current Tennessee players can look at Crochet's journey as proof that the SEC provides the level of competition and exposure necessary to reach the highest levels of professional baseball. His success also validates the program's ability to develop pitchers who can succeed in the major leagues.

Looking Forward: Championship Expectations

The Red Sox's investment in Crochet reflects their belief that they're building a championship-caliber team around young talent. With Crochet anchoring the rotation, Boston expects to contend for American League East titles and beyond throughout the duration of his contract.

For Crochet, the contract represents both validation and expectation. He's achieved financial security that seemed impossible during his injury-plagued 2022 season, but now faces the pressure of living up to one of the largest contracts ever given to a pitcher with his limited experience.

The Verdict on Boston's Gamble

Only time will determine whether the Red Sox's $170 million investment in Garrett Crochet proves prescient or problematic. What's certain is that they've committed to a pitcher whose journey from Tennessee Volunteer to franchise cornerstone represents one of the more remarkable stories in recent baseball history.

Crochet's story embodies the modern baseball landscape, where teams are increasingly willing to bet big on upside and potential rather than waiting for proven track records. His success or failure will likely influence how teams approach similar decisions in the future.

For now, the former Tennessee Volunteer is focused on justifying Boston's faith while establishing himself among the elite left-handed starters in baseball. The pressure is immense, but if his journey from college standout to injury comeback to $170 million man has proven anything, it's that Garrett Crochet thrives when the stakes are highest.

---

For fans who love tracking stories like these, FanDaily offers exclusive alumni updates and alumni insights delivering the latest on NCAA alumni thriving in the pros. Check out our Pro Pipeline tool at https://fandaily.io/pro-pipeline to discover how many alumni from any school are currently playing in the NBA, WNBA, NFL, and other professional leagues. Our comprehensive tracking system helps you follow your favorite programs' professional journeys with detailed alumni breakdowns and league-by-league analysis.